Source: Non-Billable
Charlie Geffen doesn’t mince words. The former Ashurst senior partner and Gibson Dunn private equity co-chair delivered uncomfortable truths about Big Law that most leaders won’t say publicly.
“The Global Magic Circle is Entirely American”
After four decades watching the City’s transformation, Geffen’s verdict is unequivocal: UK firms lost the global legal market to America. “The top English firms are fighting for a place in the global silver circle,” he states. Translation: game over.
Why US dominance is permanent:
- America’s domestic market dwarfs anything outside the US
- US companies export capital globally and want their lawyers with them
- DOJ investigations keep massive litigation practices perpetually busy
- Single global P&Ls promote collaboration, while UK firms’ departmental silos breed competition
The cultural gap matters too. “The closest confidant to a US chief executive tends to be the general counsel, whereas in the UK it’s probably the CFO.”
On Law Firms Cutting Deals with Trump
When firms like Paul Weiss struck deals with the Trump administration after threats, Geffen defended them in the Financial Times. His reasoning was pragmatic, not political.
“Law firms may look powerful and successful, but they are quite fragile. We saw with Arthur Andersen how they can literally collapse within weeks,” he explains. “If you fall out with the government, the government is always more powerful.”
His blunt assessment: expecting Paul Weiss to sacrifice itself was unrealistic.
The Transatlantic Merger Reality
Whilst praising recent A&O Shearman and Herbert Smith Freehills-Kramer deals as “very good,” Geffen poses the uncomfortable question: Can these ever be anything but US-led?
“In ten years’ time, the senior leadership of A&O will probably look quite different,” he predicts, code for American dominance.
His own experience at Ashurst, where Latham merger talks failed, taught him why: “Neither firm really understood what compromises were necessary.” The deeper issue? “There’s a natural anxiety to merge into something bigger. You’re giving up that visceral feeling of control.”
What’s Coming Next
Two forces will reshape Big Law:
AI Revolution: “You don’t need as many people in these firms. The skill base will be about how you input and use AI.”
Private Equity Consolidation: “Law is hugely fragmented. There is plenty of scope for consolidation.” PE firms are circling, seeing opportunity in an industry ripe for rollups.
The Bottom Line
Geffen’s message is clear: US firms won the global legal market, English firms are fighting for second place, and anyone pretending otherwise is delusional. In this new reality, pragmatism beats principle, whether that’s accepting American leadership in mergers or cutting deals with hostile administrations.
The partnership model will survive, but everything else is negotiable. Success means knowing exactly what your firm is, and more importantly, what it isn’t trying to be.
Read More: Non-Billable
